891 E 58th St,
Brooklyn, NY 11234

2,394 sqft
891 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234 is a Residential Multi-Family of 2,394 SqFt. built in 1960 on a 1,950 SqFt. lot within Kings county. The latest transaction was a Bargain and Sale Deed purchase on 12/13/1999 for $240,000. Its current estimated value is $1,015,000 and is currently off-market.
Last Sold for $240,000
$1,015,000 estimate
Built in 1960
Last Sold in 1999
2,394 sqft
1,950 lot size
$424 /sqft

Home Highlights

Parking

Parking Information

• Garage Features: Garage

Construction

Type & Styling • Home Type: Duplex 2 Units • Property Subtype: Residential
Condition • Year Built: 1960 • Flood Zone: X - Low/Medium Risk

Financial

• Purchase Method: Financed • Owners / Type: 2 / Trust • Open Loans / Balance: 2 / $77,874
• Taxes Assessed Value: $67,560 • APN: 07762-0042
Show more
property public records template

Public records available for owners of 891 E 58th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234

  • Contact Information
  • Current & Past Addresses
  • Properties & Assets
  • Businesses & Licenses

Market Analysis

Estimated Value History

According to our records, the estimated value for 891 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234 has increased by 22 % in the last 4 years.
YearEstimated value improvementAppreciation
2026$67,560$15,120 +29 %
($6/sqft)
2024$52,440($6,480) -11 %
(($3)/sqft)
2023$58,920$3,360 +6 %
($1/sqft)
2022$55,560-

Estimated Home Value Comparison

Compared to other properties in Brooklyn, 891 E 58th St is valued 1.3 % lower than the neighborhood median, 1.3 % lower than the average home price, and 47.3 % lower than the typical price per square foot.
By Neighborhood Brooklyn, NY
Median Home Value
$1,028,000 1.3 %
Average Home Value
$1,028,000 1.3 %
Average Price Per SqFt.
$803.89 47.3 %
By ZIP Code 11234
Median Home Value
$816,000 24.4 %
Average Home Value
$816,000 24.4 %
Average Price Per SqFt.
$561 24.4 %

Price history & Tax Information

Price History

891 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234 was last sold for $240,000 on 12/13/1999.
DateAmountTermEvent
12/13/1999$240,000360Bargain and Sale Deed

Tax History

According to public records, in 2025, property tax for 891 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234 decreased by $- (-).
YearAssessed ValueTax AmountTax Rate (%)Change RateImprovement Value
2026$67,560---$58,680
2025-$7,271-100 %-
2024$52,440$7,27114 %-$43,560

Nearby Schools provided by great schools icon

There are 22 schools nearby Brooklyn, NY which include the following district(s): New York City Geographic District #22, Hebrew Language Academy, and SUCCESS ACADEMY CS - BERGEN BEACH.

Preschool

6/10
Ps 207 Elizabeth G Leary Public • PK, K-8
7/10
Ps 236 Mill Basin Public • PK, K-5
6/10
Ps 312 Bergen Beach Public • PK, K-5
8/10
Ps 203 Floyd Bennett Public • PK, K-5
5/10
Ps 251 Paerdegat Public • PK, K-5

Elementary schools

6/10
Ps 207 Elizabeth G Leary Public • PK, K-8
7/10
Ps 222 Katherine R Snyder Public • K-5
7/10
Ps 236 Mill Basin Public • PK, K-5
6/10
Ps 312 Bergen Beach Public • PK, K-5
8/10
Ps 203 Floyd Bennett Public • PK, K-5

Middle schools

6/10
Jhs 78 Roy H Mann Public • 6-8
6/10
Ps 207 Elizabeth G Leary Public • PK, K-8
N/A
Mary Queen of Heaven Catholic Academy Private • PK-8
N/A
Midwood Catholic Academy Private • PK, K-8
N/A
St Bernard Elementary School Private • PK, K-8

High schools

N/A
Zvi Dov Roth Academy Of Yeshiva Rambam Private • 9, 11-12
N/A
New York City Geographic District #22 PK, K-12

Comparables

There is currently 1 comparable. Here's the most similar home for sale in Brooklyn, NY.
Address Property Type Beds Baths Sqft Distance
5510 Avenue H, Brooklyn, NY 11234 Multi-Family 5 - 2,260 0.14 mi

Owners & Tenants

206SmaxqEuIErwEr1J has owned this property for the last 320 months, and currently does have this property as their primary residence. Other people linked to the property include: Cherilia Lxalus, Christian Exallus, Eliane Thelemaque, Jeanpierre Stfleur, Jeheiam Blair
Cherilia Lxalus Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 88 Also known as Cherilia Exalus
Christian Exallus Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 89 Related to Icianise Exallus
Eliane Thelemaque Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 60 Related to Antoine Jeanpierre, Dorothy Pierre, Florence Pierrepaul Also known as Elian Jean Pierre Thelem, Eliane Jean Thelemaque
Jeanpierre Stfleur Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 72 Lived in Long Is City, NY Related to Festin St. Also known as Stslevr Jeanpierre, St Jeanpierre
Jeheiam Blair Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 26
Pierot Julien Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 49 Lived in East Orange, NJ Also known as Julien Pierot
Spentz Francois Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 34 Also known as Shenika Francob
Terry Mckenzie Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 43 Related to Jermaine Mckenzie, Seido Mckenzie, Terry Mckenzie Also known as Terry Mc Kenzie
Terry Wellington Mckenzie Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 43 Related to Jermaine Mckenzie, Seido Mckenzie, Terry Mckenzie Also known as Terry Wellington, Terry Wellingtonmckenzie
Yolette Benjamin Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 67 Related to Benjamin Louisnor, Marie Benjamin, Wagner Benjamin Also known as Yol Benjaminjeanfra, Jeanfra Benjamin

Investment Analysis

Tax Delinquency No Short Sale No Owner/Type 2 / Trust Vacant No

Liens, Foreclosure, Eviction & Probate

Uncover records with Liens, Evictions, and Foreclosures associated with 891 E 58th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234.
Pre-foreclosure No Property Line No Pre-probate No

11234 Housing Profile

According to public records, 67 % of residents in the 11234 area are homeowners, while the remaining 33 % rent their homes. The median rent is $1,771, and the average household size is 2.67 people per home.