51 E 58th St,
Brooklyn, NY 11203

2,350 sqft
51 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11203 is a of 2,350 Sq. Ft. built in 1945. The latest purchase was on 12/9/2025 for $830,000.
Last Sold for $830,000
Built in 1945
Last Sold in 2025
2,350 sqft
$- /sqft

Home Highlights

Construction

Condition • Year Built: 1945

Financial

• Owners / Type: 2 / -
property public records template

Public records available for owners of 51 E 58th St, Brooklyn, NY 11203

  • Contact Information
  • Current & Past Addresses
  • Properties & Assets
  • Businesses & Licenses

Market Analysis

Estimated Value History

Estimated value can be valuable information when deciding on purchasing a property. Find out the estimated value of 51 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11203 with PeopleFinders.

Estimated Home Value Comparison

Compared to other properties in Brooklyn, 51 E 58th St is valued 19.3 % lower than the neighborhood median, 19.3 % lower than the average home price, and 56.1 % lower than the typical price per square foot.
By Neighborhood Brooklyn, NY
Median Home Value
$1,028,000 19.3 %
Average Home Value
$1,028,000 19.3 %
Average Price Per SqFt.
$803.89 56.1 %
By ZIP Code 11203
Median Home Value
$775,500 7 %
Average Home Value
$775,500 7 %
Average Price Per SqFt.
$467.69 24.5 %

Price history & Tax Information

Price History

51 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11203 was last sold for $830,000 on 12/9/2025.
According to public records, the last transaction for this property was in 12/9/2025 for $830,000.

Tax History

Tax history can be valuable information when deciding on purchasing a property. Find out the tax history of 51 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11203 with PeopleFinders.

Nearby Schools provided by great schools icon

There are 51 schools nearby Brooklyn, NY which include the following district(s): New York City Geographic District #17, New York City Geographic District #18, Achievement First Crown Heights Charter School, Kings Collegiate Charter School, Lefferts Gardens ASCEND Charter School (Lgacs), and Ivy Hill Preparatory Charter School.

Preschool

6/10
Ps 91 The Albany Avenue School Public • PK, K-5
4/10
Ps 135 Sheldon A Brookner Public • PK, K-5
5/10
Ps 181 Public • PK, K-8
7/10
Ps 208 Elsa Ebeling Public • PK, K-5
5/10
PS 235 Janice Marie Knight School Public • PK, K-5

Elementary schools

6/10
Ps 91 The Albany Avenue School Public • PK, K-5
4/10
Ps 135 Sheldon A Brookner Public • PK, K-5
5/10
Ps 181 Public • PK, K-8
7/10
Ps 208 Elsa Ebeling Public • PK, K-5
5/10
PS 235 Janice Marie Knight School Public • PK, K-5

Middle schools

5/10
Ps 181 Public • PK, K-8
6/10
Is 285 Meyer Levin Public • 6-8
N/A
Ebenezer Preparatory School Private • PK, K-8
N/A
Excelsior Elementary School Private • 6-12
N/A
Great Oaks Elementary School Private • K-8

High schools

N/A
Nazareth Regional High School Private • 9-12
N/A
Catherine Mc Auley High School Private • 9-12
N/A
Excelsior Elementary School Private • 6-12
N/A
Bnos Menachem Private • PK-12
5/10
High School for Public Service-Heroes of Tomorrow Public • 9-12

Comparables

There are currently no similar homes for sale in Brooklyn, NY.

Owners & Tenants

Other people linked to the property include: Anna Epstein, Anwar Overton, Barbara Holmes, Duane Overton
Anna B Epstein Brooklyn, NY
Deceased 2009, Age 89 Lived in Suffern, NY Staten Island, NY Related to Bonnie Epstein, Corey Epstein, Eugene Epstein Also known as Ann Epstein, Anne Epstein
Anwar Overton Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 44 Related to Duane Overton, Julien Overton, Yvette Overton Also known as Onwar Overton
Barbara H Holmes Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 91 Lived in New York, NY Related to Dusha Holmes, Jamal Holmes, Tyrone Holmes Also known as Yvette Holmes, Barbara Holms
Duane Overton Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 41 Lived in Teaneck, NJ Related to Anwar Overton, Duane Overton, Yvette Overton
Duane D Overton Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 71 Lived in Bronx, NY New York, NY Related to Yvette Overton, Anwar Overton, Duane Overton Also known as Dwayne Overton
Jamal D Holmes Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 54 Lived in New York, NY Related to Barbara Holmes, Dusha Holmes, Jamal Holmes Also known as D Holmes
Rochel Charytan Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 44 Related to Devora Hershkop, Naftoli Charytan, Toba Charytan Also known as Rochel Yarmush
Shawn Holmes Brooklyn, NY Current location
Tyrone P Holmes Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 68 Lived in New York, NY Related to Barbara Holmes, Dusha Holmes, Jamal Holmes
Yvette B Overton Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 73 Lived in New York, NY Related to Duane Overton, Anwar Overton, Barbara Holmes Also known as Yvette Holmes

Investment Analysis

Owner/Type 2 / -

11203 Housing Profile

According to public records, 39 % of residents in the 11203 area are homeowners, while the remaining 61 % rent their homes. The median rent is $1,566, and the average household size is 2.54 people per home.