1876 58th St,
Brooklyn, NY 11204

6 beds • 4 baths • 2,915 sqft
1876 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11204 is a Residential House of 2,915 SqFt. built in 1925 on a 1,603 SqFt. lot within Kings county. It has 6 bedrooms, and 4 bathrooms. The latest transaction was a Deed purchase on 1/14/2026. Its current estimated value is $3,391,000 and is currently off-market.
$3,391,000 estimate
Built in 1925
Last Sold in 2026
2,915 sqft
1,603 lot size
$1,163 /sqft

Home Highlights

Interior

Bedrooms & Bathrooms • Bedrooms: 6 • Bathrooms: 4

Construction

Type & Styling • Home Type: Single Family • Property Subtype: Residential
Condition • Year Built: 1925 • Flood Zone: X - Low/Medium Risk

Financial

• Purchase Method: Financed • Owners / Type: 1 / Corporate • Open Loans / Balance: 2 / $742,870
• Taxes Assessed Value: $143,040 • APN: 05505-0038
Show more
property public records template

Public records available for owners of 1876 58th St, Brooklyn, NY 11204

  • Contact Information
  • Current & Past Addresses
  • Properties & Assets
  • Businesses & Licenses

Market Analysis

Estimated Value History

According to our records, the estimated value for 1876 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11204 has increased by 20 % in the last 4 years.
YearEstimated value improvementAppreciation
2026$143,040$16,620 +13 %
($6/sqft)
2023$126,420$7,380 +6 %
($3/sqft)
2022$119,040-

Estimated Home Value Comparison

Compared to other properties in Brooklyn, 1876 58th St is valued 229.9 % higher than the neighborhood median, 229.9 % higher than the average home price, and 44.7 % higher than the typical price per square foot.
By Neighborhood Brooklyn, NY
Median Home Value
$1,028,000 229.9 %
Average Home Value
$1,028,000 229.9 %
Average Price Per SqFt.
$803.89 44.7 %
By ZIP Code 11204
Median Home Value
$1,439,000 135.6 %
Average Home Value
$1,439,000 135.6 %
Average Price Per SqFt.
$868.76 33.9 %

Price history & Tax Information

Price History

1876 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11204 was last sold on 1/14/2026.
DateAmountTermEvent
1/14/2026--Deed
8/23/2016$425,000-Deed
5/11/2004$406,000360Deed

Tax History

According to public records, in 2025, property tax for 1876 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11204 increased by $663 (5 %).
YearAssessed ValueTax AmountTax Rate (%)Change RateImprovement Value
2026$143,040---$120,060
2025-$13,035---
2024-$12,372---

Nearby Schools provided by great schools icon

There are 58 schools nearby Brooklyn, NY which include the following district(s): New York City Geographic District #20, New York City Geographic District #21, New York City Special Schools - District 75, and SUCCESS ACADEMY CHARTER SCHOOL - BENSONHURST.

Preschool

4/10
Ps 48 Mapleton Public • PK, K-5
8/10
Ps 177 The Marlboro Public • PK, K-5
8/10
The Seeall Academy Public • PK, K-8
7/10
Ps 192 Magnet School For Math And Science Inquiry Public • PK, K-8
7/10
Ps 205 Clarion Public • PK, K-5

Elementary schools

4/10
Ps 48 Mapleton Public • PK, K-5
7/10
Ps 121 Nelson A Rockefeller Public • K-8
8/10
Ps 177 The Marlboro Public • PK, K-5
8/10
The Seeall Academy Public • PK, K-8
7/10
Ps 192 Magnet School For Math And Science Inquiry Public • PK, K-8

Middle schools

6/10
I.S. 96 Seth Low Public • 6-8
7/10
Ps 121 Nelson A Rockefeller Public • K-8
8/10
The Seeall Academy Public • PK, K-8
7/10
Ps 192 Magnet School For Math And Science Inquiry Public • PK, K-8
6/10
Jhs 223 The Montauk Public • 6-8

High schools

3/10
Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School Public • 9-12
N/A
Bishop Kearney High School Private • 9-12
N/A
Yeshiva Karlin Stolin Private • PK, K-12
N/A
Yeshiva Shaarei Yosher Private • 9-12
N/A
Yeshiva & Misivta Tiferes Elimelech Private • K-12

Comparables

There is currently 1 comparable. Here's the most similar home for sale in Brooklyn, NY.
Address Property Type Beds Baths Sqft Distance
1868 61st St, Brooklyn, NY 11204 House 0 - 3,160 0.15 mi

Owners & Tenants

8wrai9Vg6TyYdIRFgZ has owned this property for the last 7 months, and currently does not have this property as their primary residence. Other people linked to the property include: Avrohom Shchori, Blimi Felsenstein, Chaya Shchori, David Senbach
Avrohom N Shchori Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 25 Related to Chaya Shchori, Shmuel Shchori, Chaim Garfinkel
Blimi V Felsenstein Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 51 Related to Mazal Felsenstein, Shlomo Felsenstein, Yael Felsenstein Also known as Blimavered Felsenstein
Chaya Shchori Brooklyn, NY Current location
Age 47 Lived in New York, NY Related to Avrohom Shchori, Chaim Garfinkel, Shmuel Shchori Also known as Chaya Garfinkel, Chaya Garfinkel-Shchori
David Senbach Brooklyn, NY Current location

Investment Analysis

Tax Delinquency No Short Sale No Owner/Type 1 / Corporate Vacant No

Liens, Foreclosure, Eviction & Probate

Uncover records with Liens, Evictions, and Foreclosures associated with 1876 58th St, Brooklyn, NY 11204.
Pre-foreclosure No Property Line No Pre-probate No

11204 Housing Profile

According to public records, 35 % of residents in the 11204 area are homeowners, while the remaining 65 % rent their homes. The median rent is $1,751, and the average household size is 3.22 people per home.