1135 E 58th St,
Brooklyn, NY 11234
2,583 sqft
1135 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234 is a Residential Multi-Family of 2,583 SqFt. built in 1965 on a 2,633 SqFt. lot within Kings county. The latest transaction was a Deed purchase on 4/13/2026. Its current estimated value is $1,115,000 and is currently off-market.
$1,115,000 estimate
Built in 1965
Last Sold in 2026
2,583 sqft
2,633 lot size
$432 /sqft
Home Highlights
Construction
Type & Styling
• Home Type: Duplex 2 Units
• Property Subtype: Residential
• Building Style: Brick
Condition
• Year Built: 1965
• Flood Zone: X - Low/Medium Risk
Financial
• Purchase Method: Cash
• Owners / Type: 1 / Individual
• Open Loans / Balance: 3 / $513,709
• Taxes Assessed Value: $72,540
• APN: 07806-0016
Public records available for owners of 1135 E 58th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234
- Contact Information
- Current & Past Addresses
- Properties & Assets
- Businesses & Licenses
Market Analysis
Estimated Value History
According to our records, the estimated value for 1135 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234 has increased by 18 % in the last 4 years.
| Year | Estimated value improvement | Appreciation |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $72,540 | $7,380 +11 % ($3/sqft) |
| 2023 | $65,160 | $3,720 +6 % ($1/sqft) |
| 2022 | $61,440 | - |
Estimated Home Value Comparison
Compared to other properties in Brooklyn, 1135 E 58th St is valued 8.5 % higher than the neighborhood median,
8.5 % higher than the average home price, and 46.3 %
lower than the typical price per square foot.
By Neighborhood
Brooklyn, NY
Median Home Value
Average Home Value
Average Price Per SqFt.
By ZIP Code
11234
Median Home Value
Average Home Value
Average Price Per SqFt.
Price history & Tax Information
Price History
1135 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234 was last sold on 4/13/2026.| Date | Amount | Term | Event |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4/13/2026 | - | - | Deed |
| 4/11/2000 | $300,000 | 360 | Bargain and Sale Deed |
Tax History
According to public records, in 2025, property tax for 1135 E 58Th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234 decreased by ($4) (0 %).| Year | Assessed Value | Tax Amount | Tax Rate (%) | Change Rate | Improvement Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $72,540 | - | - | - | $60,900 |
| 2025 | - | $9,658 | - | - | - |
| 2024 | - | $9,662 | - | - | - |
Nearby Schools
provided by
There are 22 schools nearby
Brooklyn, NY
which include the following district(s): New York City Geographic District #22, Hebrew Language Academy, and SUCCESS ACADEMY CS - BERGEN BEACH.
Preschool
Ps 207 Elizabeth G Leary
Public • PK, K-8
Ps 236 Mill Basin
Public • PK, K-5
Ps 312 Bergen Beach
Public • PK, K-5
Ps 203 Floyd Bennett
Public • PK, K-5
Ps 251 Paerdegat
Public • PK, K-5
Elementary schools
Ps 207 Elizabeth G Leary
Public • PK, K-8
Ps 222 Katherine R Snyder
Public • K-5
Ps 236 Mill Basin
Public • PK, K-5
Ps 312 Bergen Beach
Public • PK, K-5
Ps 203 Floyd Bennett
Public • PK, K-5
Middle schools
Jhs 78 Roy H Mann
Public • 6-8
Ps 207 Elizabeth G Leary
Public • PK, K-8
Mary Queen of Heaven Catholic Academy
Private • PK-8
Midwood Catholic Academy
Private • PK, K-8
St Bernard Elementary School
Private • PK, K-8
High schools
Zvi Dov Roth Academy Of Yeshiva Rambam
Private • 9, 11-12
Comparables
There is currently 1 comparable. Here's the most similar home for sale in Brooklyn, NY.| Address | Property Type | Beds | Baths | Sqft | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1070 E 59th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234 | Multi-Family | 5 | 3 | 2,240 | 0.02 mi |
Owners & Tenants
EqXrfZnrR7cadQNP has owned this property for the last 4 months, and currently does not have this property as their primary residence. Other people linked to the property include: Andrea Whyte, Bridgitte Penso, Gianni Penso, Sean Penso
Andrea R Whyte
Brooklyn, NY
Current location
Age
59
Lived in
New York, NY Ware, MA
Related to
Jhanell Graham, Patrice Graham, Andradie Brown
Also known as
Andrea White, Andrea Graham
Bridgitte M Penso
Brooklyn, NY
Current location
Age
57
Lived in
Miami, FL
Related to
Alaysia Penso, Blaine Williams, Brigitte Penso
Also known as
Brigitte Penso, Bridgette Penso
Gianni C Penso
Brooklyn, NY
Current location
Age
28
Related to
Bridgitte Penso, Brigitte Penso, Gianni Penso
Gianni R Penso
Brooklyn, NY
Current location
Age
28
Related to
Bridgitte Penso, Brigitte Penso, Gianni Penso
Sean A Penso
Brooklyn, NY
Current location
Age
33
Related to
Bridgitte Penso, Brigitte Penso, Gianni Penso
Investment Analysis
Tax Delinquency
No
Short Sale
No
Owner/Type
1 / Individual
Vacant
No
Liens, Foreclosure, Eviction & Probate
Uncover records with Liens, Evictions, and Foreclosures associated with 1135 E 58th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234.
Pre-foreclosure
No
Property Line
No
Pre-probate
No
11234 Housing Profile
According to public records, 67 % of residents in the 11234 area are homeowners, while the remaining 33 % rent their homes. The median rent is $1,771, and the average household size is 2.67 people per home.